The Hong Kong 2019-20 budget paves a cautious and conservative road for the year ahead. China Briefing looks at the winners and losers of the budget and whether it does enough to address Hong Kong’s key challenges.
In late February, Hong Kong’s Finance Secretary Paul Chan unveiled the special administrative region’s 2019-20 budget. Every year, the budget sets out the financial plan for the year ahead and how the government plans to tackle economic growth, redistribution, and revenue sourcing.
This year’s budget comes as Hong Kong faces two new challenges: integrating into the Greater Bay Area with Macau and mainland China, and weathering the effects of the US-China trade war. The budget puts forward a conservative response to these issues, reflecting the heightened political and economic uncertainty in the international landscape.
Here, we highlight some of the key features of the budget and assess how this year’s budget allocations measure up in addressing some of Hong Kong’s biggest challenges.
Pursuing a diversified economy
Despite some minor changes, the composition of expenditure and revenue in this year’s budget varies very little from last year, and follows a similar theme of diversifying the economy and alleviating costs for local people and businesses.
However, the government expects a significantly lower surplus compared to the previous year. This year’s budget targets a fiscal surplus of HK$58.7 billion (US$7.48 billion), which is a 60 percent decline from the HK$138 billion (US$17.6 billion) recorded last year.
As China’s economy continues to open up, Hong Kong is left with the challenge of rebranding itself beyond its status as the gateway to the mainland.
To do this, Hong Kong has focused attention on diversifying its industries beyond China-oriented financial and professional services. The government has also emphasized the importance of integration into the Greater Bay Area (GBA), which is a super-region likened to California’s Silicon Valley that includes Hong Kong, Macau, and nine cities in neighboring Guangdong province.
The challenge, as explained by the Finance Secretary Paul Chan, is to form a ‘holistic strategy’ that plays to Hong Kong’s natural strengths in the finance, construction, and professional services industries, while bolstering opportunities in emerging sectors such as technology, innovation, and creative services.
Currently, the financial, trading, logistics, and professional services industries represent an overwhelming 57 percent of Hong Kong’s GDP in 2017.
Under the new budget, these pillar industries will be further strengthened with the following amounts earmarked to support their growth:
- Financial services: HK$400 million (US$50.98 million) as seed capital for the Financial Reporting Council to enable it to waive levy in the first two years under the new regulatory regime;
- Tourism: HK$353 million (US$45 million) for the continued implementation of the Development Blueprint for Hong Kong’s tourism industry;
- Construction: HK$40 million (US$5.09 million) to enhance public construction projects; and
- Professional services: HK$150 million (US$19.11 million) to support the development of online international dispute resolution platforms by non-government organizations.
However, according to the Finance Secretary, these traditional pillar industries are also highly susceptible to change, which leaves Hong Kong particularly vulnerable in the face growing isolationism and economic uncertainty. As a result, the government has devoted considerable resources to pivot towards new industries.
Paul Dwyer, Head of International Tax and Transfer Pricing at Dezan Shira & Associates observed, “This year’s budget places a strong emphasis on developing Hong Kong’s innovation and technology capabilities, as Hong Kong prepares to take on a more central role in R&D and technology, as indicated by the Greater Bay Area Outline Development Plan.”
Some of the technology and innovation funding includes:
- HK$5.5 billion (US$700 million) to further develop Cyberport, Hong Kong’s central hub for startups;
- HK$16 billion (US$2.04 billion) for R&D at universities;
- HK$20 billion (US$2.55 billion) for the Research Grants Council to provide research funding;
- HK$2 billion (US$255 million) for the Re-industrialization Funding Scheme;
- HK$200 million (US$25.49 million) to expand the Corporate Venture Fund of the Science Park;
- HK$800 million (US$101.94 million) to support R&D at universities, key laboratories, and engineering research centers; and
- An increased monthly allowance for researchers under the Research Programme.
In addition, creative industries, such as film, design, and fashion also stand to benefit under this new budget, with HK$1 billion (US$130 million) allocated to these industries. This is the same amount as last year, though this time some of it is earmarked to support film development.
Support for education, healthcare, and housing
Social welfare, education, and healthcare continue to be at the forefront of Hong Kong’s agenda and have seen the largest increases in spending – growing at a faster rate (10-15 percent) than the economy (3-5 percent).
The budget provides various “sweeteners” that provide immediate relief for the poor, elderly, and students. These include:
- An extra month of standard allowance for social security recipients;
- HK$2,500 (US$318.56) cash handouts for all students in financial need;
- An additional HK$1.36 billion (US$170 million) for elderly services; and
- HK$700 million (US$89.20 million) to raise allowances of medical staff and hire more medical professionals.
However, while expenditure is at an all-time high, many have criticized the government for a lack of complementary oversight to ensure the desired effects are carried out.
Education, for example, was the single largest area of government expenditure in 2019-20. It is set to receive HK$124 billion (US$15.80 billion) in funding – 20 percent of total expenditures – including a one-off grant for students and a promise to support candidates sitting the 2020 DSE exam.
However, these measures only touch the surface of Hong Kong’s education needs.
Alberto Vettoretti, Managing Partner at Dezan Shira and Associates explained, “Hong Kong is the only city to boast of four of the world’s top 100 universities. But top US or UK universities are still seen as better options as Hong Kong education is lacking in many areas, such as the sciences, which have become relevant to present day needs.”
More pressing than education, however, is Hong Kong’s housing crisis. By most measures, Hong Kong has the least affordable housing in the world, but the issue garnered an underwhelming amount of attention in the budget. The government included some targets to generate more housing supply, but did not offer significant ways to alleviate housing costs.
“The government should do a lot more over housing prices if they want to create a nurturing environment,” Vettoretti said. “Forcing a young family to live in ‘shoe-box’ or nano-apartments is simply contributing to the social unrest.”
Although it is a pressing issue, the Hong Kong government has not presented a sustainable solution to the housing shortage.
In making this point, Vettoretti reasoned, “It seems that the current trend is to tap into the infrastructure connecting Hong Kong with the PRD to push youngsters to eventually take up a place in China and live there, given the limitations in Hong Kong. This is helping with Hong Kong’s integration but not solving the housing issue.”
Vettoretti continued, “In reality, this means, if you are rich or smart or work for an organization with deep pockets, you can likely make a decent living in Hong Kong, while the rest have the option to live elsewhere in the GBA.”
Budget falls short of expectations
This year’s budget presents some clear winners – such as the financial, innovation, and technology sectors – and some clear losers – such as home-buyers and young people, more generally.
Dwyer stated, “Education and healthcare, two sectors that received some of the highest amount of funding, have also been criticized for addressing surface level issues rather than targeting the underlying factors that contribute to Hong Kong’s poor health and education opportunities.”
Although the budget touches on all the right issues, as a whole it has fallen short of expectations and has received a record-low rating from residents.
Vettoretti remarked, “Polls conducted by the University of Hong Kong show that local government ratings in Hong Kong are some of the lowest in the world. In a period fraught with uncertainties and challenges, many expected a stronger resolve to tackle some of Hong Kong’s biggest domestic challenges.”
The budget appears as though it will do enough to keep Hong Kong’s economy stable over the coming year. However, the lack of commitment to redressing the city’s underlying challenges may only make them even more pressing a year from now.
“While Hong Kong’s economy continues to grow at a relatively steady pace of three percent, ongoing issues that are left unaddressed in the budget make this growth hard to sustain in the long-term,” Vettoretti concluded.
“This year’s budget provides some concession to workers, students, and the more vulnerable communities, but it does not do enough to address key issues, such as the housing crisis, talent retention, and teaching the educational skills in demand in the world today.”
China Briefing is produced by Dezan Shira & Associates. The firm assists foreign investors throughout Asia from offices across the world, including in Dalian, Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou, Shenzhen, and Hong Kong. Readers may write firstname.lastname@example.org for more support on doing business in China.