×

Menu

  • Other Briefings
    • Asia Briefing
    • China Briefing
    • ASEAN Briefing
    • India Briefing
    • Vietnam Briefing
    • Silk Road Briefing
    • Russia Briefing
    • Middle East Briefing
    • EN
    • FR
    • DE
    • IT
    • RU
    • ES
    • CN
    • PT
  • Subscribe
Close
  • Economy & Trade

    Top Articles in Economy & Trade

    China’s 2023 Government Work Report: Highlights from the Two Sessions

    China’s 2023 Government Work Report: Highlights from the Two Sessions

    Mar 29

    We discuss the policies and targets for tax, foreign investment, consumption, healthcare, and more outlined in the 2023 Government Work Report.

    • Zelenskyy Invites Xi Jinping To Ukraine

      Mar 29
    • Belt And Road Weekly Investor Intelligence #126   

      Mar 28
    • China and Honduras Establish Diplomatic Relations

      Mar 28
    • China Reopening After COVID: Latest Developments and Business Advisory

      Mar 23
    • The Putin-Xi Summit – Their Joint Statement and Analysis

      Mar 22
    • China to Lift Restrictions on Australian Coal Imports

      Mar 22
    Read All
  • Industries

    Top Articles in Industries

    Investing in China’s Healthcare Sector – New Issue of China Briefing Magazine

    Investing in China’s Healthcare Sector – New Issue of China Briefing Magazine

    Mar 29

    China is a highly promising market for the global healthcare industry, yet it's highly competitive and regulated. Download our latest China Briefing magazine to learn more.

    • China’s Auditing, Accounting, and Tax Services Industry

      Mar 07
    • Investing in China’s Meat Industry: Trends and Opportunities

      Feb 28
    • Is China’s ‘Tech Crackdown’ Over? Our 2023 Regulatory Outlook for the Sector

      Feb 22
    • The ChatGPT Gold Rush: Everything You Need to Know

      Feb 16
    • China’s Winter Sports Market: Outlook and Opportunities for Foreign Players

      Jan 26
    • China’s Beer Market: Outlook and Opportunities

      Jan 13
    Read All
  • Tax & Accounting

    Top Articles in Tax & Accounting

    E-Invoicing in China 2023: Expansion of the Fully Digitalized E-Fapiao Program (Updated)

    E-Invoicing in China 2023: Expansion of the Fully Digitalized E-Fapiao Program (Updated)

    Mar 30

    We discuss the expansion of e-invoicing in China as the digital e-fapiao program widens its pilot roll-out with unique features.

    • China Extends Raft of Preferential Tax Policies and Fee Cuts

      Mar 29
    • China's Tax Incentives for Small Businesses (Updated)

      Mar 29
    • What Are the Tax Incentives in China to Encourage Technology Innovation? (updated)

      Mar 29
    • Preparing for China’s Annual CIT Filing: How to Deal with Book-Tax Differences

      Mar 13
    • Hong Kong Budget 2023-24: Speedy Recovery and the Path to Normalcy

      Feb 23
    • China Fully Implements New IPO Rules – Understanding the Registration-Based Mechanism for Public Listings (Updated)

      Feb 22
    Read All
  • Legal & Regulatory

    Top Articles in Legal & Regulatory

    China's Draft Certification Standards for Cross-Border Personal Information Transfer (Updated)

    China's Draft Certification Standards for Cross-Border Personal Information Transfer (Updated)

    Mar 28

    China's standards committee has begun soliciting feedback on standards for third-party agencies to certify companies for personal information export.

    • China's Corporate Social Credit System: What Businesses Need to Know

      Mar 24
    • Chinese Advertising Law: Market Regulator Issues Guidelines on the Use of “Absolute Terms”

      Mar 23
    • China Joins Apostille Convention, Simplifying the Use of Foreign Documents

      Mar 21
    • China Resumes Accepting Applications for Commercial Performances

      Mar 20
    • 2023 Two Sessions in China: How the State Council Has Been Restructured and Why

      Mar 09
    • China Takes Steps to Empower Women: Latest Developments in Women's Protection Law

      Mar 08
    Read All
  • HR & Payroll

    Top Articles in HR & Payroll

    China Resumes 144-hour Visa-Free Transit Policy for Foreigners - Who Can Apply?

    China Resumes 144-hour Visa-Free Transit Policy for Foreigners - Who Can Apply?

    Mar 27

    We explain who is eligible to enter China under the 144-hour visa-free transit policy and where you can travel on the entry permit.

    • Childcare Leave in China (Last Updated on March 24, 2023)

      Mar 24
    • China Releases Reference Texts for Better Protection of Female Employees

      Mar 16
    • China to Resume Issuing All Types of Visas for Foreigners

      Mar 14
    • China Takes Steps to Empower Women: Latest Developments in Women's Protection Law

      Mar 08
    • A Guide to Minimum Wages in China in 2023 (Last Updated on February 21, 2023)

      Feb 21
    • Mainland China to Fully Resume Travel with Hong Kong and Macao

      Feb 03
    Read All
  • Technology

    Top Articles in Technology

    E-Invoicing in China 2023: Expansion of the Fully Digitalized E-Fapiao Program (Updated)

    E-Invoicing in China 2023: Expansion of the Fully Digitalized E-Fapiao Program (Updated)

    Mar 30

    We discuss the expansion of e-invoicing in China as the digital e-fapiao program widens its pilot roll-out with unique features.

    • China's Draft Certification Standards for Cross-Border Personal Information Transfer (Updated)

      Mar 28
    • US-China Relations in the Biden Era: A Timeline

      Mar 20
    • Standard Contract Measures for Personal Information Export to Come into Force June 1

      Mar 03
    • The ChatGPT Gold Rush: Everything You Need to Know

      Feb 16
    • China has a New Plan to Strengthen its Data Economy

      Jan 23
    • UPDATE: Finalized China Data Protection Measures for Industrial and Telecom Companies Released

      Dec 29
    Read All
  • Events

    Upcoming Events

    • 31Mar
      UK-China Medical Devices Market Access Roundtable
    • 20Apr
      Understanding China's Trademark System: How FIEs can Safeguard Their Brands
    More Events

    Watch

    • How to Prepare Your China Annual Individual Income Tax Reconciliation (ATR) for 2022
      How to Prepare Your China Annual Individual Income Tax Reconciliation (ATR) for 2022
      webinar
    • A Year of Reconnecting: Why Australian Companies Are Eyeing a Re-Visit to China
      A Year of Reconnecting: Why Australian Companies Are Eyeing a Re-Visit to China
      webinar
    • Investing In China’s Financial Services Industry Regulations, Benefits and Case Studies
      Investing In China’s Financial Services Industry Regulations, Benefits and Case Studies
      webinar
    More Events
  • Publications

    Latest Guides

    An Introduction to Doing Business in China 2023 for US Companies Download Now

    An Introduction to Doing Business in China 2023 for US Companies

    Understanding China’s Greater Bay Area: Opportunities for Italian Companies Download Now

    Understanding China’s Greater Bay Area: Opportunities for Italian Companies

    An Introduction to Doing Business in China 2023 for US Companies Download Now

    An Introduction to Doing Business in China 2023 for US Companies

    More Guides

    Latest Magazines

    Investing in China’s Healthcare Sector Download Now

    Investing in China’s Healthcare Sector

    China M&A Outlook: Trends and Strategies Download Now

    China M&A Outlook: Trends and Strategies

    Investing in Green and Low-Carbon China Download Now

    Investing in Green and Low-Carbon China

    More Magazines
  • Media

    Press and Media information

    • About China Briefing
    • About Asia Briefing
    • Download Media Kit
    • Our Partners
    • Asia Briefing Bookstore
    • Contact Us
    • Our Team
    • Asiapedia Library

    About China Briefing

    China Briefing has developed into a premium source for insight on doing business in China. It publishes business news concerning foreign direct investment into China, including the most important tax, legal and accounting issues. The China Briefing Magazine was first published in 2009, and is contributed to by investment professionals based in China.

  • Doing Business

    Guides to Doing Business in China

    Why China

    Why China

    Where to Invest

    Where to Invest

    Sector Insights

    Sector Insights

    Setting Up a Business

    Setting Up a Business

    Tax & Accounting

    Tax & Accounting

    HR & Payroll

    HR & Payroll

    Browse or Search over 100 Doing Business Guides

    Doing Business in China

    China Briefing’s Doing Business guide provides vital economic, geographic, and regulatory insights for business investors, managers, or expats to understand China. Find spotlight and explainer articles, news updates, factsheets, useful tools, as well as webinars featuring on-the-ground advisors.

    Find out more
    DSA

China Makes Up US Trade War Deficit by Buying from ASEAN, Belt and Road Countries

August 14, 2019 Posted by China Briefing Written by Chris Devonshire-Ellis Reading Time: 7 minutes

China is balancing the US trade slowdown with more bilateral trade with ASEAN and Belt and Road Initiative countries. 

Op/Ed by Chris Devonshire-Ellis 

The trade war instigated by US President Trump is having an effect – but it’s not one that Washington DC will like to hear. The issue has just begun to sink in as the US deferred the latest round of tariffs to until December. Postponing the tariffs will do little to alter China’s new trajectory. The simple truth is that China’s share of bilateral trade with Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) countries, coupled with increasing trade with ASEAN, is more than compensating for any US trade downturn. This is why Chinese President Xi can afford to be ambivalent about the latest round of tariffs slapped on Chinese products to the US. It is also why Washington DC appears to be having second thoughts.

While reducing its US imports, China has instead bought more from other countries, and especially from BRI countries. The big winners have been African and Latin American countries, many of which signed off on BRI MoUs last year. This can be seen in the graphic below, which shows a huge increase in Chinese buying from alternative markets and US purchases declining significantly over the year.

In fact, the US tariffs on Chinese exports have had the opposite effect to that intended when President Trump stated his actions would reduce the Chinese trade deficit with the US. When the tariffs began, China instead pressurized its businesses to find alternative suppliers, which increased the China trade deficit with the US to just two percent of GDP. In the opposite direction, the US global trade deficit has expanded by eight percent, while the emerging market trade balance with China has moved towards a surplus – great news for ASEAN and BRI signatories.

This re-balancing is also something we have seen within Dezan Shira & Associates. Although we have a significant US client portfolio, we are not experiencing that many issues. Clients engaged in China trade have been evolving. Our firm has clients from some 70 different countries – and 69 of them do not have tariff disputes with China. China-ASEAN bilateral trade is up 4.2 percent year-on-year and hit US$293 billion in the six months to June 2019, while ASEAN became China’s second largest trade partner during that time. What is taking place is effectively an American decline. US products and services being sold to China are gradually being replaced by those from Eurasia.

Alberto Vettoretti, Managing Partner of the firm in China, states “ASEAN and China trade volumes have been growing for quite some time so this will likely intensify going forward. Red hot destinations include Indonesia, Singapore, and Vietnam, which are all heavily involved in how supply chains and trade are moving across the region, while Thailand and the Philippines are also experiencing large growth volumes.”

ASEAN nations are also experiencing high GDP growth rates this year as a result.

This is easily explained by China’s Free Trade Agreement with ASEAN, which has deleted tariffs on some 95 percent of all products and services traded between them. Someone in Washington DC didn’t do their homework: China has free trade options to the US, and only needed to increase purchases.

In terms of the BRI, China has not only been busy signing MoUs with interested nations, it has been going a step further by committing to a lengthy series of Double Tax Agreements, which also reduce taxes on specific products on a case by case basis. How far this extends can be seen below.

This explains why China has been buying more products from emerging markets.

Additionally, China is now at a stage with the BRI when it actively wants foreign, third-party participation. This was specifically catered for in the latest additions to China’s Foreign Investment Law, which allowed foreign participation in public procurement projects for the first time. I discussed this in the article, “China’s New Foreign Investment Law and the Impact on the Belt and Road Initiative”. I also discussed the Top 20 BRI countries purchasing from China in the article, “The Main Buyers of China’s Belt and Road Initiative Materials.”

However, there are other regional advantages coming into play as well.

The BRI will almost certainly make China more prepared than the US when it comes to waging tariff wars. For example, Chinese businesses have been heavily investing in Africa over the past five years, establishing subsidiaries throughout the continent. These companies are domiciled as African, and are now poised to take huge trade advantages from the recent African Continental Free Trade Agreement (AfCFTA), which removes tariffs of 90 percent on all products traded across Africa. With DTAs also in place with many African countries, Chinese businesses are beginning an African trade bonanza. I wrote about the impact this would have in the article, “China’s African Moves through the Belt & Road, Double Tax Treaties, and AfCFTA”. So much for what President Trump dismissed as “shithole countries.” They are now replacing US producers for the China market.

It’s a similar, if rather more diverse story in South America, which I covered in the article “China’s Belt and Road in South America”, where countries, such as Venezuela, Guyana, Suriname, Ecuador, Bolivia, Uruguay, and Chile have all signed off on China’s BRI. It is a developing scenario, but one that can be expected to accelerate in terms of DTA and BRI trade in coming years. China has not yet made roads into Central America, so as not to overly push the US too far, but as Trump continues to build his wall with Mexico, these countries may feel better off under trade generated with Beijing rather than Washington DC. My comments on this can be read in the article, “China’s Belt and Road in Mexico and Central America”. These current, and almost guaranteed, trade partners with China will find trade opportunities with Beijing as Washington DC rejects them.

It’s a similar “in progress” story across Eurasia, where the two competing blocs are Brussels and Moscow. Moscow is the leading partner in the Eurasian Economic Union, which includes Armenia, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Russia itself. While that might sound an unlikely grouping, it wields real geopolitical influence as it effectively covers a land mass that stretches from China to the borders of the EU.

The development of the EAEU is catching many analysts by surprise. The EAEU-China FTA signed last year was largely dismissed in academic and trade circles as it was non-preferential, meaning it didn’t include any specific categories of goods. However, this rather misses the point – getting the FTA arrangement started is the salient point, as products can simply be added at a later date, without the need for intensive negotiations. This means the China-EAEU FTA can roll-out the product specifics when China and Russia determine the time is right. In Trumpian terms, it is in fact “locked and loaded” – all that is needed is the addition of product categories. When enacted, it is likely to take many analysts by surprise, and it is already apparent that Russia and China are negotiating a product and service specific FTA between them and the members of the EAEU right now, as confirmed by presidents Xi and Putin in May.

These differing paths between China and the US effectively means their respective positions have swapped.

The impact of the US-China tariff war will long be felt, and especially by US citizens and US companies overseas. Many of the latter, however, are already adapting to life externally from a US-based perspective. Some will become far more global and cease being “American” businesses in all perhaps but name.

However, what does now seem apparent, when trade figures, and developments instigated by China, become more clear, is that the trade war is effectively already over. The sad thing about the US is that as China’s national purchasing strategy has changed, and it shifts its supplier base away from the US, those American businesses are highly unlikely to get that China market share back.

Asia is far closer, more predictable, and acts with rather more trade sustainability than Washington DC trade policy appears capable of providing. Global businesses need to have sustainable and predictable logistics and trade relationships in place to continue to provide a demanding and rapidly growing worldwide market.

It is unfair to place this all upon Trump’s shoulders; the decline has been there for some time. The US, generally, has been overly bombastic about its own strengths, while neglecting the hard work and efforts that need to be put in place on the ground.

This includes a shocking neglect of bilateral trade ties, agreements, and investment treaties, some of which are still current, despite being 20 years out of date. The increasingly odious talk of American superiority has drowned out the real diplomatic work that underpins ongoing relations, which have been relegated to an afterthought amid all the pro-US bombast.

Instead, that calm, longer term global strategic diplomatic play is now being provided for by China, while the US is rapidly being relegated to the status of an unpredictable market, and one in which the extension of the deadline of imposition of further tariffs on Chinese products until December only serves to prolong the uncertainty.

Instead, the smart money is investing in China, ASEAN, and the emerging markets of the BRI. It is important to be on the right side of history in this struggle, and that increasingly means working with and properly understanding a sustainable and predictable China – and the trade initiatives it brings along for the ride.

About Us

China Briefing is written by Dezan Shira & Associates. Chris Devonshire-Ellis is the Founding Partner. The firm assists foreign investors throughout Asia and has done since 1992, servicing clients from offices across China, Hong Kong, ASEAN, India, and the Belt & Road. Please contact us at china@dezshira.com or visit us at www.dezshira.com.

  • Previous Article Investing in India’s Maharashtra State, Vietnam’s Port Infrastructure – China Outbound
  • Next Article In Trump’s Remodelling of the US, the North Pole is in China

 

Events in China All Events

Our free webinars are packed full of useful information for doing business in China.

Related reading
  • An Introduction to Doing Business in China 2023
  • A Quick Guide to Accounting and Audit in China 2023 (1st Edition)
  • Tax, Accounting, and Audit in China 2022-23
  • China M&A Outlook: Trends and Strategies
  • Human Resources and Payroll in China 2022
DEZAN SHIRA & ASSOCIATES

DEZAN SHIRA & ASSOCIATES

Meet the firm behind our content. Visit their website to see how their services can help your business succeed.

About Us Find an Advisor
China Briefing Weekly Newsletter
Want the Latest Sent to Your Inbox?

Subscribing grants you this, plus free access to our articles and magazines.

SUBSCRIBE

Get free access to our subscriptions and publications

Subscribe to receive weekly China Briefing news updates,
our latest doing business publications, and access to our Asia archives.

Sign Up Now
Subscribe to China Briefing
About Us
  • Overview
  • Personnel
  • News
  • Events
  • Subscribe
Topics
  • Economy & Trade
  • Tax & Accounting
  • Legal & Regulatory
  • Industries
  • HR & Payroll
Bookstore
  • Visit Publication
  • My Account
  • My Order History
  • Products
Media Partners
  • Partner
©1992-2023 Dezan Shira & Associates All Rights Reserved.
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
×
China Briefing Weekly Newsletter

Sign up for your complimentary subscription to our weekly newsletter here.

No subscription charges!

China Breifing
×

Search our guides, media and news archives

Type keyword to begin searching...

Back to top