×

Menu

  • Other Briefings
    • Asia Briefing
    • China Briefing
    • ASEAN Briefing
    • India Briefing
    • Vietnam Briefing
    • Silk Road Briefing
    • Russia Briefing
    • Middle East Briefing
    • EN
    • FR
    • DE
    • IT
    • RU
    • ES
    • CN
    • PT
  • Subscribe
Close
  • Economy & Trade

    Top Articles in Economy & Trade

    China’s 2023 Government Work Report: Highlights from the Two Sessions

    China’s 2023 Government Work Report: Highlights from the Two Sessions

    Mar 29

    We discuss the policies and targets for tax, foreign investment, consumption, healthcare, and more outlined in the 2023 Government Work Report.

    • Zelenskyy Invites Xi Jinping To Ukraine

      Mar 29
    • Belt And Road Weekly Investor Intelligence #126   

      Mar 28
    • China and Honduras Establish Diplomatic Relations

      Mar 28
    • China Reopening After COVID: Latest Developments and Business Advisory

      Mar 23
    • The Putin-Xi Summit – Their Joint Statement and Analysis

      Mar 22
    • China to Lift Restrictions on Australian Coal Imports

      Mar 22
    Read All
  • Industries

    Top Articles in Industries

    Investing in China’s Healthcare Sector – New Issue of China Briefing Magazine

    Investing in China’s Healthcare Sector – New Issue of China Briefing Magazine

    Mar 29

    China is a highly promising market for the global healthcare industry, yet it's highly competitive and regulated. Download our latest China Briefing magazine to learn more.

    • China’s Auditing, Accounting, and Tax Services Industry

      Mar 07
    • Investing in China’s Meat Industry: Trends and Opportunities

      Feb 28
    • Is China’s ‘Tech Crackdown’ Over? Our 2023 Regulatory Outlook for the Sector

      Feb 22
    • The ChatGPT Gold Rush: Everything You Need to Know

      Feb 16
    • China’s Winter Sports Market: Outlook and Opportunities for Foreign Players

      Jan 26
    • China’s Beer Market: Outlook and Opportunities

      Jan 13
    Read All
  • Tax & Accounting

    Top Articles in Tax & Accounting

    E-Invoicing in China 2023: Expansion of the Fully Digitalized E-Fapiao Program (Updated)

    E-Invoicing in China 2023: Expansion of the Fully Digitalized E-Fapiao Program (Updated)

    Mar 30

    We discuss the expansion of e-invoicing in China as the digital e-fapiao program widens its pilot roll-out with unique features.

    • China Extends Raft of Preferential Tax Policies and Fee Cuts

      Mar 29
    • China's Tax Incentives for Small Businesses (Updated)

      Mar 29
    • What Are the Tax Incentives in China to Encourage Technology Innovation? (updated)

      Mar 29
    • Preparing for China’s Annual CIT Filing: How to Deal with Book-Tax Differences

      Mar 13
    • Hong Kong Budget 2023-24: Speedy Recovery and the Path to Normalcy

      Feb 23
    • China Fully Implements New IPO Rules – Understanding the Registration-Based Mechanism for Public Listings (Updated)

      Feb 22
    Read All
  • Legal & Regulatory

    Top Articles in Legal & Regulatory

    China's Draft Certification Standards for Cross-Border Personal Information Transfer (Updated)

    China's Draft Certification Standards for Cross-Border Personal Information Transfer (Updated)

    Mar 28

    China's standards committee has begun soliciting feedback on standards for third-party agencies to certify companies for personal information export.

    • China's Corporate Social Credit System: What Businesses Need to Know

      Mar 24
    • Chinese Advertising Law: Market Regulator Issues Guidelines on the Use of “Absolute Terms”

      Mar 23
    • China Joins Apostille Convention, Simplifying the Use of Foreign Documents

      Mar 21
    • China Resumes Accepting Applications for Commercial Performances

      Mar 20
    • 2023 Two Sessions in China: How the State Council Has Been Restructured and Why

      Mar 09
    • China Takes Steps to Empower Women: Latest Developments in Women's Protection Law

      Mar 08
    Read All
  • HR & Payroll

    Top Articles in HR & Payroll

    China Resumes 144-hour Visa-Free Transit Policy for Foreigners - Who Can Apply?

    China Resumes 144-hour Visa-Free Transit Policy for Foreigners - Who Can Apply?

    Mar 27

    We explain who is eligible to enter China under the 144-hour visa-free transit policy and where you can travel on the entry permit.

    • Childcare Leave in China (Last Updated on March 24, 2023)

      Mar 24
    • China Releases Reference Texts for Better Protection of Female Employees

      Mar 16
    • China to Resume Issuing All Types of Visas for Foreigners

      Mar 14
    • China Takes Steps to Empower Women: Latest Developments in Women's Protection Law

      Mar 08
    • A Guide to Minimum Wages in China in 2023 (Last Updated on February 21, 2023)

      Feb 21
    • Mainland China to Fully Resume Travel with Hong Kong and Macao

      Feb 03
    Read All
  • Technology

    Top Articles in Technology

    E-Invoicing in China 2023: Expansion of the Fully Digitalized E-Fapiao Program (Updated)

    E-Invoicing in China 2023: Expansion of the Fully Digitalized E-Fapiao Program (Updated)

    Mar 30

    We discuss the expansion of e-invoicing in China as the digital e-fapiao program widens its pilot roll-out with unique features.

    • China's Draft Certification Standards for Cross-Border Personal Information Transfer (Updated)

      Mar 28
    • US-China Relations in the Biden Era: A Timeline

      Mar 20
    • Standard Contract Measures for Personal Information Export to Come into Force June 1

      Mar 03
    • The ChatGPT Gold Rush: Everything You Need to Know

      Feb 16
    • China has a New Plan to Strengthen its Data Economy

      Jan 23
    • UPDATE: Finalized China Data Protection Measures for Industrial and Telecom Companies Released

      Dec 29
    Read All
  • Events

    Upcoming Events

    • 31Mar
      UK-China Medical Devices Market Access Roundtable
    • 20Apr
      Understanding China's Trademark System: How FIEs can Safeguard Their Brands
    More Events

    Watch

    • How to Prepare Your China Annual Individual Income Tax Reconciliation (ATR) for 2022
      How to Prepare Your China Annual Individual Income Tax Reconciliation (ATR) for 2022
      webinar
    • A Year of Reconnecting: Why Australian Companies Are Eyeing a Re-Visit to China
      A Year of Reconnecting: Why Australian Companies Are Eyeing a Re-Visit to China
      webinar
    • Investing In China’s Financial Services Industry Regulations, Benefits and Case Studies
      Investing In China’s Financial Services Industry Regulations, Benefits and Case Studies
      webinar
    More Events
  • Publications

    Latest Guides

    An Introduction to Doing Business in China 2023 for US Companies Download Now

    An Introduction to Doing Business in China 2023 for US Companies

    Understanding China’s Greater Bay Area: Opportunities for Italian Companies Download Now

    Understanding China’s Greater Bay Area: Opportunities for Italian Companies

    An Introduction to Doing Business in China 2023 for US Companies Download Now

    An Introduction to Doing Business in China 2023 for US Companies

    More Guides

    Latest Magazines

    Investing in China’s Healthcare Sector Download Now

    Investing in China’s Healthcare Sector

    China M&A Outlook: Trends and Strategies Download Now

    China M&A Outlook: Trends and Strategies

    Investing in Green and Low-Carbon China Download Now

    Investing in Green and Low-Carbon China

    More Magazines
  • Media

    Press and Media information

    • About China Briefing
    • About Asia Briefing
    • Download Media Kit
    • Our Partners
    • Asia Briefing Bookstore
    • Contact Us
    • Our Team
    • Asiapedia Library

    About China Briefing

    China Briefing has developed into a premium source for insight on doing business in China. It publishes business news concerning foreign direct investment into China, including the most important tax, legal and accounting issues. The China Briefing Magazine was first published in 2009, and is contributed to by investment professionals based in China.

  • Doing Business

    Guides to Doing Business in China

    Why China

    Why China

    Where to Invest

    Where to Invest

    Sector Insights

    Sector Insights

    Setting Up a Business

    Setting Up a Business

    Tax & Accounting

    Tax & Accounting

    HR & Payroll

    HR & Payroll

    Browse or Search over 100 Doing Business Guides

    Doing Business in China

    China Briefing’s Doing Business guide provides vital economic, geographic, and regulatory insights for business investors, managers, or expats to understand China. Find spotlight and explainer articles, news updates, factsheets, useful tools, as well as webinars featuring on-the-ground advisors.

    Find out more
    DSA

Covid-19 Carriers: What Do China’s Wildlife Protection Laws Say about Pangolins?

April 1, 2020 Posted by China Briefing Reading Time: 6 minutes

Editor’s note:

On February 24, the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress, China’s top legislature body, issued a decision to totally ban the illegal trade and consumption of wildlife as food. Use of wild animals for medicine, pets, and scientific research will be subject to “strict examination and approval” by the supervising departments. On March 31, Guangdong province became the first Chinese province to revise its local regulation on wildlife protection. From May 1, 2020, anyone who eats wild animals of national priority protection may be fined up to 20 times the value of the wildlife.

Op/Ed by Chris Devonshire-Ellis 

Eating pangolins and other wild animals – what do China’s wildlife protection laws say? 

While the source of the now-named Covid-19 coronavirus that has so seriously affected China has yet to be fully determined, suspicions are falling upon the Chinese Pangolin (Manis pentadactyla) as the most likely creature to have harbored the virus and then passed it to humans. 99 percent of the RNA of a coronavirus found in Pangolins is identical to Covid-19.

Pangolins are a type of anteater yet are considered a gourmet food across much of Asia. They are, however, endangered and are listed as a Category 2 protected species by CITES, to which China is a signatory. There have been calls to upgrade the pangolins’ status to Category 1, the highest, as its population has plummeted in the past decade, mainly as a result of poaching.

This means there is a disconnect between wildlife protection treaties that China signs up to and the actual behavior of some of its own citizens. That is an educational issue, and better wildlife protection and education of the Chinese of a national basis of the perils in consuming such creatures may have prevented such a catastrophe of the type we see today.

Covid-19, meanwhile, may just prove to be the savior of Chinese pangolins. They are unlikely to be back on the menu anytime soon.

Pangolins are used both as a gourmet meal – they are said to be delicious while the scales are used in traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). There are decent profits to be made by poachers; the meat sells for close to US$300 a kilo, while the scales fetch up to US$3,000 a kilogram.

Sun Xiuqing, a TCM doctor at Jingshan Hospital in Beijing was quoted saying in this rather distressing article that “Roast pangolin scales are used, combined with other TCM material, to promote blood circulation, dispel clotting or swelling, and it is used more often on women who want to stimulate lactation after giving birth, or on people who suffer from cancer.”

This tradition continues despite studies showing that there is no apparent benefit from consuming pangolin scales at all – they are made of keratin, the same as human fingernails.

So, the Chinese have signed up to CITES, but what do China’s own laws in terms of wildlife protection say?

China has a Wildlife Protection Law of the People’s Republic of China (amended in 2018).

According to this, all wildlife under national protection is divided into Grade I and Grade II categories of protection. This is reviewed every 5 years. Grade 1 animals are rarer and are under tighter protection, which means hunting them illegally may be punished more severely, while obtaining approvals for special license hunting is more difficult – applications need to be made to the Wildlife Conservation Department, which is under the direction of the State Council.

The most recent lists of protected animals in China can be found here. China generally follows CITES categorization, the panda, for example, is Grade 1 protected, while pangolins are Grade 2. According to the law, it is forbidden to hunt or kill wildlife under national protection (Article 21) without holding a special hunting license.

Article 41 outlines the penalties for breaking the law and illegally hunting nationally protected wild animals. These are:

  • Confiscation of hunted objects, tools, and illegal gains;
  • Revocation of other hunting licenses;
  • A fine of more than two times and less than ten times the value of the property seized; if no property is seized, a fine of 10,000 yuan to 50,000 yuan (US$1,434 to US$7,173) shall be imposed; and
  • If a crime is constituted, criminal responsibility shall be investigated according to law.

This now brings us to China’s Criminal Law on the subject, where Article 341 states: illegal hunting and killing rare and endangered wildlife under special state protection shall be sentenced to up to 10 years fixed-term imprisonment, along with fines and confiscation of property. The clause in full:

“Whoever illegally catches or kills the species of wildlife under special state protection which are rare or near extinction, or illegally purchases, transports or sells the species of wildlife under special state protection which are rare or near extinction and their products shall be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of not more than five years or criminal detention and concurrently be sentenced to a fine; if the circumstances are serious, the offender shall be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of not less than five years and not more than ten years and concurrently be sentenced to a fine; if the circumstances are especially serious, the offender shall be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of not less than ten years and concurrently be sentenced to a fine or confiscation of property.

Whoever, in violation of game laws or regulations, hunts in a game reserve, during a period when hunting is prohibited or using implements or methods that are prohibited, thereby damaging wildlife resources shall, if the circumstances are serious, be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of not more than three years, criminal detention, public surveillance or a fine.”

There appears to be no differences between punishments handed out for abuses of animals in Grade 1, or Grade 2, which leads us to believe these are probably discretionary.  The Criminal Law especially is hard on convicted poachers, although the Wildlife law is less severe. Given that the China Biodiversity Conservation and Green Development Foundation (CBCGDF) estimates 60,000 wild pangolins were killed in China in 2018 alone, it is obvious the law, while on the statute, is not being upheld.

Pangolin can fairly easily be sourced in China, and there is a vibrant, if illegal online market for not just pangolin but other wildlife products. This is an image of them that appeared on the Pinduoduo website (subsequently removed):

The outbreak of Covid-19 therefore has serious educational, regulatory, and industry implications for China. These can be identified as follows:

  • China’s wildlife laws need to be upgraded in terms of applicable punishment. Whoever caught and sold a suspected pangolin in Wuhan did so for a profit of a few hundred dollars. The impact cost will run into hundreds of billions of dollars and produce a death toll way into the hundreds.
  • China’s criminal laws need to be enforced in every case of breaching the wildlife laws and the tough sentences already described within them implemented.

There are additional, wider ranging, and more problematic issues to deal with in the longer term.

  • Online stores in China should face stiffer penalties for advertising illegal products;
  • China’s traditional wet markets need to be better governed and managed, including regular and thorough checks. Vendors and the Chinese rural population, in particular, need better education concerning hygiene, the quality of produce, the desirability of keeping differing food products apart, ban the sale of wild animals, and curtail the entrance of wild animals such as birds, pigeons, and rodents;
  • Wealthier Chinese need to be properly educated about the risks of eating wild animals. “Face” can be obtained instead via an expensive bottle of cognac or rare maotai – this is an educational and marketing issue;
  • Chinese traditional medicine (TCM) is a multi-billion dollar industry in China, yet it is partially responsible for upholding discredited beliefs and quackery. It needs to be far better regulated. The consumption of items, such as pangolin scales, is rooted in the medieval, Ming dynasty past and does not belong to the modern, scientific society China aims to be.

Bringing the TCM market under better scientific and regulatory control will be a massive task for the CCP. The global market for products is estimated to be worth US$50 billion per annum, and many practitioners swear by it. However, many of the ingredients can be synthesized, and others are long based in ridiculous theories – consuming tiger penis making men more virile, for example. Dealing with TCM’s popularity in China is a huge political ask while the basis for it remains a symbol of national pride and beliefs. There are some acknowledged benefits to many TCM applications; however, the results of these can vary from patient to patient unless the specific active beneficial ingredient can be found. Yet, many preparations are against conducting such research; maintaining the mystery is a preferred sales and magical recovery tool.

Yet, it is clear such beliefs are partially responsible for the Covid-19 outbreak. Somehow the CCP need to find a way to deal with the issue. Writing in Forbes, Sergei Klebnikov says that the World Bank estimates that at best outcome, providing the Covid-19 outbreak doesn’t become more serious, global growth will be impacted by about US$500 billion this year. The political question for China is this: With the TCM industry worth US$50 billion, how many more outbreaks is it going to take before the government starts to make TCM, its beliefs, practices, and trading standards more accountable? And when will it start to uphold its own laws? China, and its own citizens, need to take stock of which traditions are valuable in their society, and in the aftermath of the coronavirus, which ones should now be cast aside.

Related Reading

    • China’s Latest Regional Measures to Support SMEs during the Coronavirus Outbreak
    • China’s Support for Foreign Investors, Trading Companies as Coronavirus Impacts Supply Chains
    • Managing Your China Business during the Coronavirus Outbreak: Ongoing Updates and Advisory
    • Corporate Sustainability in China
      Faced with the new reality of a slowing economy and ongoing environmental issues, China now sees sustainability as essential to ensuring long-term viability for both its economy and its citizens’ quality of life. As the issue of sustainability gains traction in China and around the world, businesses are entering into a new era of accountability.

About Us

Chris Devonshire-Ellis is the Founding Partner and Chairman of Dezan Shira & Associates. He may be contacted at chris@dezshira.com.

Dezan Shira & Associates offer practical advice and solutions for foreign buyers and companies in the China market. If you need assistance with clarifications concerning the coronavirus and operational/supply chain issues, please contact us at china@dezshira.com or visit us at www.dezshira.com.

  • Previous Article China Business Continuity Issues That Need to Be Addressed Now
  • Next Article Shanghai-London Stock Connect Still Operating Normally: China Securities Regulatory Commission

 

Events in China All Events

Our free webinars are packed full of useful information for doing business in China.

Related reading
  • Corporate Sustainability in China
  • The New Foreign Investment Law in China
DEZAN SHIRA & ASSOCIATES

DEZAN SHIRA & ASSOCIATES

Meet the firm behind our content. Visit their website to see how their services can help your business succeed.

About Us Find an Advisor
China Briefing Weekly Newsletter
Want the Latest Sent to Your Inbox?

Subscribing grants you this, plus free access to our articles and magazines.

SUBSCRIBE

Get free access to our subscriptions and publications

Subscribe to receive weekly China Briefing news updates,
our latest doing business publications, and access to our Asia archives.

Sign Up Now
Subscribe to China Briefing
About Us
  • Overview
  • Personnel
  • News
  • Events
  • Subscribe
Topics
  • Economy & Trade
  • Tax & Accounting
  • Legal & Regulatory
  • Industries
  • HR & Payroll
Bookstore
  • Visit Publication
  • My Account
  • My Order History
  • Products
Media Partners
  • Partner
©1992-2023 Dezan Shira & Associates All Rights Reserved.
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
×
China Briefing Weekly Newsletter

Sign up for your complimentary subscription to our weekly newsletter here.

No subscription charges!

China Breifing
×

Search our guides, media and news archives

Type keyword to begin searching...

Back to top