Topics

  • Economy & trade
  • Tax & Accounting
  • Legal & regulatory
  • Industries
  • HR & Payroll
  • Technology

Features

  • Cities Spotlight
  • COVID-19 Insights
  • Opinion

Featured Events

  • May 19
    Counterstrategies for Rising Business Costs in China: Best Practices Sharing
  • May 24
    US Time Zone - How to Combat Rising Business Costs in China: Best Practices Sharing
  • Managing IP Protection When Selling to China via Cross-Border E-Commerce
    Managing IP Protection When Selling to China via Cross-Border E-Commerce
  • China's Tax Incentives for Enterprises in 2022: Updates Following the Two Sessions
    China's Tax Incentives for Enterprises in 2022: Updates Following the Two Sessions
  • Upcoming Events
  • On Demand library

Reports and Publications

Human Resources and Payroll in China 2022
How China is Reforming its Soe's to Become Mixed Hybrid Global Businesses Worth Tens of Billions of Dollars

Latest Video & Podcasts

How Your Domicile Defines Individual Income Tax Treatment in China and the UK
How Your Domicile Defines Individual Income Tax Treatment in China and the UK
Permanent Establishment and Employing People in China and the UK Series
Permanent Establishment and Employing People in China and the UK Series

About China Briefing

  • About us
  • Asia Briefing
  • Our Partners
  • Our Team
  • Media Kit
  • Contact


  • EN
  • EN
  • FR
  • DE
  • IT
  • RU
  • ES
  • CN
  • PT
SUBSCRIBE
  • Topics
  • Trump and China’s 0.4% Trade War Damp Squib

Trump and China’s 0.4% Trade War Damp Squib

March 28, 2018 Posted by China Briefing Reading Time: 4 minutes

CDE Op-Ed Commentary

The mainstream media has been full of doomsday scenarios these past few weeks concerning the potential for a China-US trade war given the tariff impositions US President Donald Trump imposed “upon China” to “stop steel dumping” and “protect American jobs”.

Bearing in mind Trump was elected on the premise of anti-China dumping, the massive trade gap the US has with China, and the “Make America Great Again” slogans designed to both protect and create American jobs, a scenario where Trump would have a go at China to satisfy his voters has always seemed likely. But as I pointed out on Russia Briefing last month, China isn’t a huge supplier of steel to the US.

Top-Sources-of-US-Steel-Imports (002)

Washington has since gone on to say that the US will impose tariffs on US$50 billion worth of imported Chinese goods, with US trade representative Robert Lighthizer saying the goal is to target 1,300 product categories. This is apparently intended to “pressure” China to alter its trade practices, regardless of the established realization that China provides the US with a lot of products where the profit margin is made by the US importers, distributors, and price markups rather than Chinese manufacturers per se. Apple, in particular, leaves a measly US$10 or so value in China for every US$800 to 1,000 iPhone 8/X they make, which is why they are the world’s most valuable company – they retain the value and profit.

Another example is in the clothing supply chain. A pair of jeans from a US brand, designed in the US, made in China on German, Japanese, or US machines from US cotton, and processed into cloth in the US on US or Swiss textile machines, and exported to China. The rivets are made from Chilean copper on German machines in China. A US quality control agent inspects them. The jeans are packed into boxes made from recycled US paper waste exported to China (that reduces US landfill pollution) on machines that come from Germany. They are then packed into shipping containers made in China, Korea, or Vietnam, owned by a US leasing firm, funded by US investors, then hauled to port by Japanese, US, or Swedish trucks on trailers made in Korea.

They are shipped on a Chinese or Korean built ship owned by a Japanese, Chinese, Taiwanese, or European shipping company, with a Filipino crew and European officers. A US Company insures them and the whole process is financed by a US trade bank. They are unloaded at a US port by American dockworkers, American customs and clearing agents inspect them, and American security guards protect them. US import taxes are paid, if applicable. They are loaded onto a US built tractor-trailer and delivered to a distribution facility, financed or leased from US bank, employing US workers. They are advertised on US owned TV, radio, and billboards (and online by the US dominated internet) using services from a US ad agency and artists. They are further distributed to the retail outlet or sold on the internet, paid for by a US owned credit card company or bank, and finally are delivered to the customer. When they are worn out, they may be reprocessed into cotton waste products, sent back to China, Bangladesh or Vietnam, where the cycle starts again.

China’s response, among the predictably enunciated political sabre rattling promising hellfire and fury, has been to impose retaliatory tariffs on US$3 billion of US goods, among them fresh fruit, nuts, wine, and pork, as well as recycled aluminum and steel pipes.

According to the Office of the United States Trade Representative, in 2016 China-US bilateral trade was worth about US$650 billion, with US exports to China amounting to US$169.8 billion and Chinese imports at US$478.8 billion, making the US goods and services trade deficit with China US$309 billion.

This means that even if the US imposed tariffs on “US$50 billion” of Chinese imports, that would affect just over 10 percent of total US imports. As for China, its targeted response of US$3 billion of additional tariffs on US imports is actually just 1.8 percent of the total. While the American figure of US$50 billion would certainly have an impact, it remains to be seen if it will actually be carried out. In fact, that amount would only impact an equivalent of 0.42 percent to China’s 2017 GDP. That’s hardly a punishment.

There are other issues. China’s tariff response has been measured and has hit back at exactly the same voters Trump is eager to protect. Rather than swinging an axe at over 1,300 different products, China has taken a measured response, designed to deliberately hurt Trump’s political base. That US$3 billion of imposed tariffs included US pork exports. The American pork industry sent US$1.1 billion in products to China last year, making it the third largest market for US pork. In total, American farmers shipped about US$20 billion of goods to China in 2017. A large part of Trumps voting base? American farmers. They are not very happy right now. In fact, forty-five US trade associations have written to Mr. Trump opposing the tariffs. Only three support them. A copy of that letter can be seen here.

In short, the amount of additional tariffs China has imposed upon the United States equates to just 0.4 percent of the total trade volume. For a trade war, that’s pretty lame. And as for China, they’ve done a good job in educating an Apprentice. The spat will rumble on a little bit more, but a trade war was never the intention, and it won’t happen.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

About Us

Chris Devonshire-Ellis is the Chairman of Dezan Shira & Associates, and has written over 20 well-received technical guides to doing business in China in a career stretching over 25 years. The firm provides business advisory, legal, tax, and on-going operational support services to foreign investors in China. Please email china@dezshira.com for further assistance. 

Previous Article
« Cross Border e-Commerce in China – New Issue of China Briefing Magazine

Next Article
China Slashes VAT Rates in US$64 Billion Tax Cut »

Related reading

  • March 28, 2018

    Dezan Shira & Associates and the United States of America

    Dezan Shira & Associates has been serving US-based companies for over 25 years. The vast majority have found success in Asia, adding value to their...

    DOWNLOAD
  • March 23, 2018

    Cross Border e-Commerce in China

    While cross border e-commerce (CBEC) is an attractive channel for foreign businesses to sell to China, misunderstandings over how CBEC in China works...

    DOWNLOAD
  • December 21, 2017

    Establishing & Operating a Business in China 2018

    China’s foreign investment landscaped changed significantly in 2017, where strategic investors will find that their options have broadened significantly....

    DOWNLOAD

Expand Your Business in Asia

Dezan Shira & Associates helps businesses establish, maintain, and grow their operations.

Learn More

New Asia Briefing Website is Live!More news, better regional coverage, and a cleaner look.VISIT ASIA BRIEFING

Recommended for you

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Stay Ahead of the curve in Emerging Asia. Our subscription service offers regular regulatory updates,
including the most recent legal, tax and accounting changes that affect your business.

About

  • Overview
  • Personnel
  • Expert Contributors
  • Social Media
  • Email Newsletter / Subscription Service

Topics

  • Economy & Trade
  • Tax & Accounting
  • Legal & Regulatory
  • Industries
  • Human Resources & Payroll

Bookstore

  • Visit Publications
  • My Account
  • My Order History
  • Products

Events

  • Upcoming Events
  • Event Archive
  • Asia Events
  • Global Events

Media Partners

  • Partners
  • Partnership Program
  • Regional Business News
  • Follow and Share
© 1992-2021 Dezan Shira & Associates All Rights Reserved.
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy

Create Account

  • The Asia Briefing Weekly newsletter
  • Downloadable magazines and guides
  • Business event invites
  • Asiapedia access
Subscribe

Already a subscriber? Log in to start browsing
our magazines and guides

LOGIN
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.

China Weekly Briefing

Sign up for your complimentary subscription to our weekly newsletter here.
No subscription charges!